Frequent readers of my blogs are aware that the Department of Labor recently issued new rules governing overtime that take effect December 1, 2016. Summer is flying by and by the time we get to Labor Day (September 5), you'll have less than 90 days to be compliant with these rules.
Here's a quick review. The salary test for most of the Fair Labor Standards Act exemptions has essentially doubled from $455 per week to $913 ($23,660 to $47,476 annually). This means unless your salaried employees spend most of their time in outside sales or meet one of the other rare exemptions, they are no longer eligible to be treated as exempt if their weekly salary is below $913 week, no matter what their duties are.
I've gotten quite a few calls asking for opinions about specific jobs in recent months, and have written a few opinion letters (each with the appropriate disclaimer that I am providing the opinion of an HR professional only and I am not an attorney nor pretending to be one). The interesting thing I find is that many of those jobs were improperly classified to begin with. They met the old salary test but failed the duties test.
It's the salary test that's been in the news this summer, but each job must also meet the standards of the duties test. And this seems to be the forgotten piece of the equation and has put many organizations at risk and they may not have known it.
So between now and December 1 make sure you've reviewed all the exempt positions in your organization to consider both the new salary test and the duties tests to make sure that you are compliant. That's the easy part. Converting everyone who needs to be reclassified to non-exempt - that's the hard part. So develop a strategy for what you're going to tell them and what is expected of them regarding the maintaining of time records, managing their hours, etc. going forward.
If you need some assistance from a third party to conduct the analysis or to communicate the message, feel free to call The Davidson Group.
Wednesday, August 3, 2016
I've Told 'em a Thousand Times!
I was sitting in a conference room waiting on an executive meeting to get started when the CEO casually mentioned to a division manager that he'd noticed something at one of the jobs. The division manager said, I've told those guys a thousand times not to do that... The CEO replied, Have you ever actually done anything about it?
Company culture is 100% based on what behaviors the organization, through its leaders and its most engaged employees, rewards, condemns and condones. I once heard a speaker say that organizations will spit out a person who doesn't belong like sour milk. Management's challenge is to make sure that good workers are spitting out bad and not vice-versa!
If a company has built a solid safety culture, for example, it will self-police unsafe work practices. I was hanging lights in a warehouse facility when one of my co-workers climbed on a short stack of pallets. We hadn't really noticed any warehouse workers back there, but before he was able to stand up, there were five of that company's workers circling the pallets yelling at him to get down immediately and go get a ladder! In that organization, safe work practices were a way of life and anyone who risked their safety record, safety bonus, whatever, was held accountable and potentially spit out.
Contrast that with the culture at an organization that constantly struggles with its workers comp mod rate and can't seem to get its employees to wear their PPE. The owner at that organization probably tells his insurance company, I've told them a thousand times..
If there are no consequences to off-brand behavior (behavior you don't want) and no rewards for on-brand behavior (behavior you do want), then your culture is going to be what the front line workers want it be. Rewards can be tangible (cash, bonuses, gift cards, promotions, etc.) or they can be intangible (recognition, public or private words of thanks, pats on the back, etc.). Consequences can also be formal (write-ups, verbal warnings, etc.) or informal (the other workers get the bonuses, the preferred shifts, public recognition, etc.).
When I was an operations manager in a service industry, I knew that terminating a worker for consistently ignoring our standards would be inconvenient and I might end up having to run a route or cover a shift myself. But I was taught and have always believed that the decision to let that worker slide just so that I will not be inconvenienced is the fork in the trail that leads to mediocrity.
The real win occurs when your front line workers begin to self-police off-brand behaviors rather than waiting for management to do it. This happens when your organization has the right mix of rewards and consequences in place, the first and second tier leaders know you are committed to the brand, and build they their teams with people that are also committed to the brand. Do that and you'll find that you don't have to tell them a thousand times anymore.
Or, you could do try it the easy way and just say it for the one thousand and first time. Maybe if you say it a little louder this time.
Company culture is 100% based on what behaviors the organization, through its leaders and its most engaged employees, rewards, condemns and condones. I once heard a speaker say that organizations will spit out a person who doesn't belong like sour milk. Management's challenge is to make sure that good workers are spitting out bad and not vice-versa!
If a company has built a solid safety culture, for example, it will self-police unsafe work practices. I was hanging lights in a warehouse facility when one of my co-workers climbed on a short stack of pallets. We hadn't really noticed any warehouse workers back there, but before he was able to stand up, there were five of that company's workers circling the pallets yelling at him to get down immediately and go get a ladder! In that organization, safe work practices were a way of life and anyone who risked their safety record, safety bonus, whatever, was held accountable and potentially spit out.
Contrast that with the culture at an organization that constantly struggles with its workers comp mod rate and can't seem to get its employees to wear their PPE. The owner at that organization probably tells his insurance company, I've told them a thousand times..
If there are no consequences to off-brand behavior (behavior you don't want) and no rewards for on-brand behavior (behavior you do want), then your culture is going to be what the front line workers want it be. Rewards can be tangible (cash, bonuses, gift cards, promotions, etc.) or they can be intangible (recognition, public or private words of thanks, pats on the back, etc.). Consequences can also be formal (write-ups, verbal warnings, etc.) or informal (the other workers get the bonuses, the preferred shifts, public recognition, etc.).
When I was an operations manager in a service industry, I knew that terminating a worker for consistently ignoring our standards would be inconvenient and I might end up having to run a route or cover a shift myself. But I was taught and have always believed that the decision to let that worker slide just so that I will not be inconvenienced is the fork in the trail that leads to mediocrity.
The real win occurs when your front line workers begin to self-police off-brand behaviors rather than waiting for management to do it. This happens when your organization has the right mix of rewards and consequences in place, the first and second tier leaders know you are committed to the brand, and build they their teams with people that are also committed to the brand. Do that and you'll find that you don't have to tell them a thousand times anymore.
Or, you could do try it the easy way and just say it for the one thousand and first time. Maybe if you say it a little louder this time.
Wednesday, July 13, 2016
What Scale is Best for Performance Reviews?
Dr. Ed Cornelius, one of my business school professors, was adamant that a traditional performance review form should have an even-numbered scale. He said it didn't matter if you chose a 4-point, a 6-point, an 8-point or a 10-point scale. He felt a mid-point - like a 3 on a 5-point scale - was a magnet for managers, and an easy way for them to cop out. An even-numbered scale has no mid-point.
I experienced this cop out once when I received a 3 out of possible 5 for Profitability when my business unit had literally tripled its budgeted profit. When I asked my VP what it would take to earn a 4, he just laughed, but didn't change the rating. Dr. Cornelius was right - mid-points really are a magnet for managers who don't take the time to properly prepare a review.
Another problem with Likert Scales like these is that the ratings seem to always be grouped around the top 3 numbers. So if an organization uses a 10 point scale, there will be a few 8s, a lot of 9s and a few 10s. If they use a 6 point scale, the ratings will distribute across 4, 5 and 6 in the same way. Most people get a B, and B is generally the number right below the top number on the scale.
So which scale is best?
If the goal of your performance management program is to provide meaningful feedback that leads to performance improvement, links to compensation and supports career development and succession initiatives, then my answer is, None of the Above!
More and more organizations have decided that rating attributes or behaviors on a Likert Scale has little impact on performance and can even be demotivating when poorly executed. I never really took my review seriously with that company after the 3 for Profitability incident. Plus there were no obvious links between my ratings and my compensation, anyway. The review devolved into an exercise that I tolerated each year so my boss could check the box. That's why organizations are abandoning their traditional Likert Scale reviews and either replacing them with something better or not replacing them at all.
But if forced to use a Likert Scale, I'll defer to a 4-point scale - that way, when the scores are distributed across 2, 3 and 4, the lowest rating will be below the mid-point of the possible ratings. But I'll be kicking and screaming that there is a better way!
If you would like to discuss alternatives to the traditional review, contact me for a free consultation.
I experienced this cop out once when I received a 3 out of possible 5 for Profitability when my business unit had literally tripled its budgeted profit. When I asked my VP what it would take to earn a 4, he just laughed, but didn't change the rating. Dr. Cornelius was right - mid-points really are a magnet for managers who don't take the time to properly prepare a review.
Another problem with Likert Scales like these is that the ratings seem to always be grouped around the top 3 numbers. So if an organization uses a 10 point scale, there will be a few 8s, a lot of 9s and a few 10s. If they use a 6 point scale, the ratings will distribute across 4, 5 and 6 in the same way. Most people get a B, and B is generally the number right below the top number on the scale.
So which scale is best?
If the goal of your performance management program is to provide meaningful feedback that leads to performance improvement, links to compensation and supports career development and succession initiatives, then my answer is, None of the Above!
More and more organizations have decided that rating attributes or behaviors on a Likert Scale has little impact on performance and can even be demotivating when poorly executed. I never really took my review seriously with that company after the 3 for Profitability incident. Plus there were no obvious links between my ratings and my compensation, anyway. The review devolved into an exercise that I tolerated each year so my boss could check the box. That's why organizations are abandoning their traditional Likert Scale reviews and either replacing them with something better or not replacing them at all.
But if forced to use a Likert Scale, I'll defer to a 4-point scale - that way, when the scores are distributed across 2, 3 and 4, the lowest rating will be below the mid-point of the possible ratings. But I'll be kicking and screaming that there is a better way!
If you would like to discuss alternatives to the traditional review, contact me for a free consultation.
How many HR people should I have?
This is a question I get asked a lot. Of course the answer is, it depends. Smaller organizations tend to have administrative employees who wear several hats. So if an office manager spends 80% of her time performing accounting tasks (including payroll) and 20% of her time dealing with employee issues, that company has 1/5th of an HR person.
Standard benchmarking practice is to exclude dedicated payroll and training/development people from the HR-per-100 employee ratio calculation. The rule-of-thumb metric I've often heard is one HR person per 100 employees. So, in the example above, the office manager can probably effectively provide HR services to up to 20 employees, assuming she knows anything about HR compliance and HR best practices. If that organization has 40 employees, their HR is probably suffering because the accounting is always going to get done.
But the 1-to-100 ratio can be misleading. According to benchmarking surveys conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management, companies with 250 and fewer employees have a ratio closer to 2-per-100 on average. Organizations with 250+ employees often have fewer than 1-per-100 due to efficiencies linked to being larger.
When I'm asked that question by organizations with 100 or fewer, I usually ask some follow-up questions before I recommend a number:
1. What is your competitive advantage (how does your company beat its competitors)?
2. What is your employee turnover rate?
3. How effective is your owner/president at assessing talent, developing talent and getting the right people in the right seats?
Cafe du Monde is a famous restaurant in New Orleans right in the heart of the French Quarter. It does a booming business because of its ideal location. I've always found the service there to be below average at best. Cafe du Monde does not need a lot of HR people because its people aren't critical to its success. A restaurant in a less desirable location that depends on its great service reputation to be successful will likely benefit from a higher HR ratio than Cafe du Monde needs.
Likewise, an organization that is in a very stable industry, doesn't have many competitors trying to pilfer its employees, and generally treats its people well won't need as much HR as a company in a high turnover, highly volatile industry where employees have lots of options.
Some owners are really good with people. People like working for them, they listen well and have a knack for positioning people to be successful. Others understand the technical aspects of their business but are terrible with employees. This second type of owner needs more HR help - to protect themselves from themselves.
The Institute for Corporate Productivity did a study a few years ago and found that the highest performing small companies have a higher ratio of HR people per 100 employees than their lower performing industry peers. This may seem counter-intuitive to the owner who sees HR as simply administrative overhead. But if that owner looks at the company he/she most admires in their industry, they'll likely see a company who invests more in their HR platform.
Standard benchmarking practice is to exclude dedicated payroll and training/development people from the HR-per-100 employee ratio calculation. The rule-of-thumb metric I've often heard is one HR person per 100 employees. So, in the example above, the office manager can probably effectively provide HR services to up to 20 employees, assuming she knows anything about HR compliance and HR best practices. If that organization has 40 employees, their HR is probably suffering because the accounting is always going to get done.
But the 1-to-100 ratio can be misleading. According to benchmarking surveys conducted by the Society for Human Resource Management, companies with 250 and fewer employees have a ratio closer to 2-per-100 on average. Organizations with 250+ employees often have fewer than 1-per-100 due to efficiencies linked to being larger.
When I'm asked that question by organizations with 100 or fewer, I usually ask some follow-up questions before I recommend a number:
1. What is your competitive advantage (how does your company beat its competitors)?
2. What is your employee turnover rate?
3. How effective is your owner/president at assessing talent, developing talent and getting the right people in the right seats?
Cafe du Monde is a famous restaurant in New Orleans right in the heart of the French Quarter. It does a booming business because of its ideal location. I've always found the service there to be below average at best. Cafe du Monde does not need a lot of HR people because its people aren't critical to its success. A restaurant in a less desirable location that depends on its great service reputation to be successful will likely benefit from a higher HR ratio than Cafe du Monde needs.
Likewise, an organization that is in a very stable industry, doesn't have many competitors trying to pilfer its employees, and generally treats its people well won't need as much HR as a company in a high turnover, highly volatile industry where employees have lots of options.
Some owners are really good with people. People like working for them, they listen well and have a knack for positioning people to be successful. Others understand the technical aspects of their business but are terrible with employees. This second type of owner needs more HR help - to protect themselves from themselves.
The Institute for Corporate Productivity did a study a few years ago and found that the highest performing small companies have a higher ratio of HR people per 100 employees than their lower performing industry peers. This may seem counter-intuitive to the owner who sees HR as simply administrative overhead. But if that owner looks at the company he/she most admires in their industry, they'll likely see a company who invests more in their HR platform.
Sunday, June 5, 2016
My Applicant has Green Hair!
One of my clients recently lost a sale. The feedback we received was that the potential customer was put off by our technician's visible tattoos and appearance.
According to the Pew Research Center, 40% of millennials have at least one tattoo. Many millennials are aware that some employers remain uneasy about body art and place their tattoos in areas that are covered by normal business dress. But I'll bet many of your applicants have not been as careful. Applicants I see for service roles and for trades and craft positions seem to have visible tattoos, piercings and unnatural hair colors at a higher rate than college grads looking for white-collar jobs.
So, how should your organization respond to this growing trend? I am reminded of a famous exchange between star basketball player Bill Walton and legendary coach John Wooden at UCLA in the early 1970's. Walton: You can't tell me how I can wear my hair, coach! Wooden: You're right Bill, but I do get to decide who plays and we're going to miss you. (here's the story)
While Coach Wooden stuck with his rigid policies, other college coaches decided to embrace the long hair trend in the 1970s. Wooden won his final championship in 1975 and the championship teams in '76, '77 and '78 had rosters full of players with longer hair than Wooden would allow. Other coaches decided hair length was no longer a deterrent to their university's brand and restrictions on hair length hurt their recruiting efforts. Sound familiar?
The first thing to review is whether your current policies accurately reflect the attitudes of your customer base. Based on the anecdotal evidence provided by a single customer, it would have been easy for my client to overreact and begin enforcing a stricter dress code for its field personnel. Fortunately, we keep metrics on technician performance and we discovered that this technician was #1 in the company in jobs closed and #2 in closing percentage over the past year. That one customer does NOT reflect the true attitudes of most of our customers, so it would have been a mistake to risk losing this technician over that one piece of feedback.
With unemployment rates dropping and the war for talent heating back up, now may be a good time to reevaluate those dress and appearance policies. Here are some things to think about:
1. Safety first - if the presence of earrings, loops, gauges, nose rings, etc. puts the employee at risk for injury or puts your product at risk for contamination, by all means ban those items from the workplace.
2. Unless you're going to stick to a "no visible tattoos allowed" policy, distinguish between offensive tattoos and tattoos in general. Gang symbols, confederate flags, sexual images and profanity pose different risks for an employer than flowers, dolphins or doves, children's names, tributes to family members and other benign images. The former can generate harassment or hostile work environment claims. Your organization must decide to what degree the latter are a business risk.
3. It is OK to have different policies for different categories of employees. No visible tattoos for outside sales people, for example, may make sense. Having no such restriction for back office, warehouse or plant floor personnel may also make sense.
It's a mistake to stereotype a candidate based on the presence of visible tattoos or green hair. Focus your interview on true predictors of success in the role - their knowledge, skills and abilities. And supplement the interview with other tools that will improve your good hire percentage (here's a previous blog on this topic). Stereotyping frequently leads to missed opportunities, no matter whether it's race, age, gender, etc. or lifestyle choices.
The main thing to remember is that if you're stuck in a rigid "no tattoo" mindset like we had in the 80s and 90s, you could be significantly shrinking the pool of potential employees (and potential star performers). Review that policy and decide if it still makes sense for your organization today. And if you're assuming your customers won't like it, find a way to survey them to ensure that your assumptions are accurate.
According to the Pew Research Center, 40% of millennials have at least one tattoo. Many millennials are aware that some employers remain uneasy about body art and place their tattoos in areas that are covered by normal business dress. But I'll bet many of your applicants have not been as careful. Applicants I see for service roles and for trades and craft positions seem to have visible tattoos, piercings and unnatural hair colors at a higher rate than college grads looking for white-collar jobs.
So, how should your organization respond to this growing trend? I am reminded of a famous exchange between star basketball player Bill Walton and legendary coach John Wooden at UCLA in the early 1970's. Walton: You can't tell me how I can wear my hair, coach! Wooden: You're right Bill, but I do get to decide who plays and we're going to miss you. (here's the story)
While Coach Wooden stuck with his rigid policies, other college coaches decided to embrace the long hair trend in the 1970s. Wooden won his final championship in 1975 and the championship teams in '76, '77 and '78 had rosters full of players with longer hair than Wooden would allow. Other coaches decided hair length was no longer a deterrent to their university's brand and restrictions on hair length hurt their recruiting efforts. Sound familiar?
The first thing to review is whether your current policies accurately reflect the attitudes of your customer base. Based on the anecdotal evidence provided by a single customer, it would have been easy for my client to overreact and begin enforcing a stricter dress code for its field personnel. Fortunately, we keep metrics on technician performance and we discovered that this technician was #1 in the company in jobs closed and #2 in closing percentage over the past year. That one customer does NOT reflect the true attitudes of most of our customers, so it would have been a mistake to risk losing this technician over that one piece of feedback.
With unemployment rates dropping and the war for talent heating back up, now may be a good time to reevaluate those dress and appearance policies. Here are some things to think about:
1. Safety first - if the presence of earrings, loops, gauges, nose rings, etc. puts the employee at risk for injury or puts your product at risk for contamination, by all means ban those items from the workplace.
2. Unless you're going to stick to a "no visible tattoos allowed" policy, distinguish between offensive tattoos and tattoos in general. Gang symbols, confederate flags, sexual images and profanity pose different risks for an employer than flowers, dolphins or doves, children's names, tributes to family members and other benign images. The former can generate harassment or hostile work environment claims. Your organization must decide to what degree the latter are a business risk.
3. It is OK to have different policies for different categories of employees. No visible tattoos for outside sales people, for example, may make sense. Having no such restriction for back office, warehouse or plant floor personnel may also make sense.
It's a mistake to stereotype a candidate based on the presence of visible tattoos or green hair. Focus your interview on true predictors of success in the role - their knowledge, skills and abilities. And supplement the interview with other tools that will improve your good hire percentage (here's a previous blog on this topic). Stereotyping frequently leads to missed opportunities, no matter whether it's race, age, gender, etc. or lifestyle choices.
The main thing to remember is that if you're stuck in a rigid "no tattoo" mindset like we had in the 80s and 90s, you could be significantly shrinking the pool of potential employees (and potential star performers). Review that policy and decide if it still makes sense for your organization today. And if you're assuming your customers won't like it, find a way to survey them to ensure that your assumptions are accurate.
The New Overtime Rules Are Here
Regular readers of my blog have seen numerous articles over the past year claiming the new overtime rules were coming. When the rules were delayed time and again, I'm sure I sounded a bit like Chicken Little - they really are coming!
Well now they're here and we know what is expected. The DOL eased up a bit on the salary test minimum from what they originally proposed. The number is now set at $47,476 annually and will go up every three years. They've also given us until December 1 to become compliant.
What this means for your organization is that, if you haven't already, now is the time to identify everyone that you pay on a salary basis rather than hourly who earns less than $47,476 annually. Then you need to develop and implement a compensation strategy for each of them. Here are a few options:
1. Raise them to the new minimum. If they're pretty close to that level now, the easiest solution may be to give them a raise and keep them exempt. But remember, they must meet the salary test and the duties test. The DOL might still consider them misclassified based on their duties, so review this as well.
2. Convert them to hourly. This may be well-received by some employees who will be happy to become eligible for overtime compensation, but may be poorly-received by others who will see it as a demotion.
3. See if salaried non-exempt or fluctuating workweek overtime will work in your situation. For some workers whose workload is heavy some weeks and light other weeks, a salaried non-exempt or fluctuating workweek structure may be a viable lower cost alternative. This may also work for employees who rarely work more than 40 hours in a week. The key here is that the employee must "win" sometimes and the employer "win" sometimes. You can't pay the lower overtime rate one week and then dock the employee for leaving early the next week. This approach will not work in situations where employees regularly and consistently work overtime or in states where it is illegal.
There are also some morale and engagement issues to consider before executing your strategy:
1. Employees moving from salaried to hourly who see this as a demotion. Hold meaningful conversations with these folks to help them understand why you're making this change, what it means to them in terms of tracking their time, and what your expectations are with regard to their working extra hours. Explain that this is not a change you would have made if not for the new regulations.
2. Employees who have worked hard to get to a $48,000 salary level only to have entry level people in their same job category now starting at $47,500. This is a case-by-case situation that organizations need to address. In many situations it's probably going to make sense to adjust compensation for these folks as well. The costs of allowing those employees to drift into a disengaged state or leave your organization altogether are probably greater than the cost of making them happy.
3. Understand the role of bonuses and commissions in achieving the minimum salary threshold. In some cases up to 10% of the $47,476 can be achieved through bonuses and commissions so long as they are performance based and paid at least quarterly.
Contact The Davidson Group if you'd like some assistance analyzing and developing strategies for your particular situation.
Well now they're here and we know what is expected. The DOL eased up a bit on the salary test minimum from what they originally proposed. The number is now set at $47,476 annually and will go up every three years. They've also given us until December 1 to become compliant.
What this means for your organization is that, if you haven't already, now is the time to identify everyone that you pay on a salary basis rather than hourly who earns less than $47,476 annually. Then you need to develop and implement a compensation strategy for each of them. Here are a few options:
1. Raise them to the new minimum. If they're pretty close to that level now, the easiest solution may be to give them a raise and keep them exempt. But remember, they must meet the salary test and the duties test. The DOL might still consider them misclassified based on their duties, so review this as well.
2. Convert them to hourly. This may be well-received by some employees who will be happy to become eligible for overtime compensation, but may be poorly-received by others who will see it as a demotion.
3. See if salaried non-exempt or fluctuating workweek overtime will work in your situation. For some workers whose workload is heavy some weeks and light other weeks, a salaried non-exempt or fluctuating workweek structure may be a viable lower cost alternative. This may also work for employees who rarely work more than 40 hours in a week. The key here is that the employee must "win" sometimes and the employer "win" sometimes. You can't pay the lower overtime rate one week and then dock the employee for leaving early the next week. This approach will not work in situations where employees regularly and consistently work overtime or in states where it is illegal.
There are also some morale and engagement issues to consider before executing your strategy:
1. Employees moving from salaried to hourly who see this as a demotion. Hold meaningful conversations with these folks to help them understand why you're making this change, what it means to them in terms of tracking their time, and what your expectations are with regard to their working extra hours. Explain that this is not a change you would have made if not for the new regulations.
2. Employees who have worked hard to get to a $48,000 salary level only to have entry level people in their same job category now starting at $47,500. This is a case-by-case situation that organizations need to address. In many situations it's probably going to make sense to adjust compensation for these folks as well. The costs of allowing those employees to drift into a disengaged state or leave your organization altogether are probably greater than the cost of making them happy.
3. Understand the role of bonuses and commissions in achieving the minimum salary threshold. In some cases up to 10% of the $47,476 can be achieved through bonuses and commissions so long as they are performance based and paid at least quarterly.
Contact The Davidson Group if you'd like some assistance analyzing and developing strategies for your particular situation.
Sunday, May 8, 2016
Advice on Criminal Background Checks
Criminal background checks are an important preemployment screen for many organizations. And rightfully so. If I own a company that sends service workers to other people's homes or businesses, I don't want to send someone I wouldn't want in my own home or business and expose my customers to potential risks they wouldn't find acceptable.
But this once commonplace practice has come under scrutiny in recent years. And the criticisms do have merit. Some segments of the population are convicted of crimes at a much higher rate than other segments, and critics suggest that requiring a criminal background check and screening out candidates for infractions that are not really job related may be a type of discrimination.
Employers should evaluate each job on its own merits. Certainly rejecting a candidate for a bookkeeper position who has a felony fraud conviction is hard to debate. But bouncing a candidate for a scaffolding erector position for a non-violent misdemeanor five years ago might be considered overzealous.
The key for employers is avoid having a blanket policy regarding what constitutes a passing or failing criminal background screen. Instead, set criteria for each job title or job grouping separately. For example, the company may set higher standards for candidates who will be driving company vehicles than those who will always be passengers or those working on the plant floor. The company might have a different set of standards for employees who will have access to cash or the company's books than for administrative roles that have no such access.
And finally, conduct the background screen post-offer! There are several advantages of conducting the screens after an offer has been made (contingent upon meeting the screening standards) versus conducting the screen in advance of the offer:
1. It's less expensive - why pay for a screen if you haven't come to financial terms with the candidate. Furthermore, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires employers send a specific kind of notice to candidates who are rejected on the basis of a criminal background or credit check. Run the screen on several finalists, and you may have to send multiple notices out.
2. It provides a much stronger defense against discrimination. If you have a signed offer letter from a minority candidate conditional upon meeting the company's standards, and those standards are reasonable, it's hard for the EEOC to conclude that your organization utilizes discriminatory hiring practices. If you conduct the screen pre-offer, you can't prove that you would have hired the minority even if the screen results were acceptable.
3. Some states don't allow pre-offer criminal background screens (it is legal in NC, SC and VA). If your organization operates in multiple states, make sure you know the law in each state.
If you really want to be an early adopter and reduce your risk with the EEOC even further, consider revising your employment application to comply with the national "ban the box" trend. This means you don't ask candidates to list any convictions on the application (thereby demonstrating that you don't reject applicants on the basis of criminal background, alone). Instead, have a statement on the application that tells applicants that the company conducts post-offer criminal background screens and that criteria varies by position.
But this once commonplace practice has come under scrutiny in recent years. And the criticisms do have merit. Some segments of the population are convicted of crimes at a much higher rate than other segments, and critics suggest that requiring a criminal background check and screening out candidates for infractions that are not really job related may be a type of discrimination.
Employers should evaluate each job on its own merits. Certainly rejecting a candidate for a bookkeeper position who has a felony fraud conviction is hard to debate. But bouncing a candidate for a scaffolding erector position for a non-violent misdemeanor five years ago might be considered overzealous.
The key for employers is avoid having a blanket policy regarding what constitutes a passing or failing criminal background screen. Instead, set criteria for each job title or job grouping separately. For example, the company may set higher standards for candidates who will be driving company vehicles than those who will always be passengers or those working on the plant floor. The company might have a different set of standards for employees who will have access to cash or the company's books than for administrative roles that have no such access.
And finally, conduct the background screen post-offer! There are several advantages of conducting the screens after an offer has been made (contingent upon meeting the screening standards) versus conducting the screen in advance of the offer:
1. It's less expensive - why pay for a screen if you haven't come to financial terms with the candidate. Furthermore, the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires employers send a specific kind of notice to candidates who are rejected on the basis of a criminal background or credit check. Run the screen on several finalists, and you may have to send multiple notices out.
2. It provides a much stronger defense against discrimination. If you have a signed offer letter from a minority candidate conditional upon meeting the company's standards, and those standards are reasonable, it's hard for the EEOC to conclude that your organization utilizes discriminatory hiring practices. If you conduct the screen pre-offer, you can't prove that you would have hired the minority even if the screen results were acceptable.
3. Some states don't allow pre-offer criminal background screens (it is legal in NC, SC and VA). If your organization operates in multiple states, make sure you know the law in each state.
If you really want to be an early adopter and reduce your risk with the EEOC even further, consider revising your employment application to comply with the national "ban the box" trend. This means you don't ask candidates to list any convictions on the application (thereby demonstrating that you don't reject applicants on the basis of criminal background, alone). Instead, have a statement on the application that tells applicants that the company conducts post-offer criminal background screens and that criteria varies by position.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)